Chris BerryFounder, Wine Underdogs — chasing the world’s overlooked grapesIf you love Pinot Grigio, you love one of two things about it: how light it is, or how easily it refreshes. You can keep both and still trade the blankness for flavour. Elbling keeps the featherweight and adds a saline snap. Verdejo keeps the easy freshness and adds herbal zest. Godello keeps the citrus core and adds body, for the night you're ready for a little more.
The short answer
- Elbling (Germany): green apple, lemon, chalk and salt. The closest match, light as anything you've ordered by the glass.
- Verdejo (Spain): grapefruit, lime, fennel and a bitter-almond finish. Pinot Grigio's ease with a personality.
- Godello (Spain): pear, quince, citrus and wet stone. The trade-up, when you want body as well as refreshment.
What do you want to keep?
Pinot Grigio is the white you order when you don't want to think about it: light, crisp, cold and inoffensive. There's nothing wrong with that, until you notice most of it barely tastes of anything. That neutrality is the whole product. So the useful question isn't what to replace it with. It's which part you'd refuse to give up. If it's the weightlessness, you want a featherweight grape. If it's the easy freshness and you'd happily take a little more weight or flavour, you have two more options.
| Grape | Keeps | Adds |
|---|---|---|
| Elbling | Featherweight body | Saline snap |
| Verdejo | Easy freshness | Herbal zest |
| Godello | Citrus core | Body and stone |
Elbling: the featherweight one
Obermosel, Germany · featherweight, bone dry · ELB-ling
This ancient German grape makes bone-dry, feather-light, high-acid whites: green apple, lemon, chalk and a saline snap. It has the low-alcohol ease of the best Pinot Grigio, and a mineral crispness that keeps it interesting. It's the refreshing white for people who thought they were bored of refreshing whites.
Versus Pinot Grigio: the closest like-for-like on this list. Same weight, same chill-and-pour ease, with something to notice on every sip.
The catch: the acid sits at the very top of the scale. If you drink Pinot Grigio because it's soft, Elbling's snap may read as sharp at first.
Look for: a producer your shop stands behind, and ask them by name.
Verdejo: the zesty one
Rueda, Spain · light body, high acid · ver-DEH-ho
Verdejo from Spain's Rueda is zesty and aromatic, with grapefruit, lime, wild fennel and a signature bitter-almond finish. It drinks as easily as Pinot Grigio and actually has a personality.
Versus Pinot Grigio: a clear step up in flavour without losing the easy freshness. If you want the same glass on a warm evening and want to taste it this time, start here.
The catch: that bitter-almond finish is the signature, and it's the one note Pinot Grigio never has. Taste a glass before you buy a case.
Look for: a producer your shop stands behind, and ask them by name.
Godello: the one with body
Valdeorras, Galicia, Spain · medium body, high acid · go-DEH-yoh
Godello from Galicia keeps a fresh, citrusy core and adds texture and a stony, mineral depth. They call it the white Burgundy of Spain. It's still refreshing, with the weight and seriousness Pinot Grigio never attempts.
Versus Pinot Grigio: the trade-up. Reach for it when you're ready for a little more and the meal can carry it.
The catch: it's the least like-for-like of the three. If weightlessness is the point, Godello will feel heavy, so go to Elbling instead.
Look for: a producer your shop stands behind, and ask them by name.
Where to buy
I haven't confirmed a specific bottle of any of these in stock online this month, so I'm not linking one. US availability is uneven, and the shop you already use may carry one of the three without shouting about it. Take the grape names in, ask what they'd pour for a Pinot Grigio drinker, and let them name the producer.
One thing I owe you plainly: I haven't tasted these three side by side yet. When I have, the bottles I'd buy go here, and this guide gets shorter.
New to the overlooked grapes? Join the Pack, one overlooked wine at a time. Or see the whole approach in Order This Instead.
Part of Lesser-Known Wines: 17 Obscure Grapes Worth Switching To, the full underdog-swap guide.
New to wine? Start here
Wine Match
Five guilty pleasures, yes or no. Ben finds the wine you’d actually like. You don’t need to know anything about wine. Ben certainly doesn’t.
Wine Underdogs is for readers of legal drinking age.
BenFive things. Yes or no. I'll do the rest.
Every wine fact here comes from the grape guides on Wine Underdogs. Ben has never opened a bottle, and neither does this game. For readers 21 and over.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good alternative to Pinot Grigio?
For the same light, crisp, refreshing style with more character, try Elbling, the featherweight, bone-dry, saline German white that's the closest match, or Verdejo for a zesty, herbal step up. Godello suits Pinot Grigio drinkers who want a little more body.
Why is Pinot Grigio often so bland?
Much commercial Pinot Grigio is made in a high-volume, neutral style designed to be inoffensive rather than expressive. The underdog whites here are grown and made for character, so you keep the easy refreshment without the blandness.
Is Pinot Grigio the same as Pinot Gris?
Yes, it is one grape with two names. The Italian name usually signals the light, early-picked, neutral style most people know. The French name, especially on a bottle from Alsace, usually signals a riper, rounder, more aromatic wine. Same vine, different intentions.
Are these as easy to drink as Pinot Grigio?
Yes. Elbling, Verdejo and Godello are all light-to-medium, high-acid whites that sit well at the table. They pour just as easily on a warm evening; they simply give you more to taste.
JOIN THE PACK
Whatever you drink now, there's an underdog you'd like more.
One overlooked wine at a time: what it tastes like, the famous one it can replace, and the catch. Free.