Chris BerryFounder, Wine Underdogs — chasing the world’s overlooked grapesIf you love Chardonnay, you love one of two things about it: the mineral seriousness of the lean, flinty kind, or the weight of the rich kind. Godello gives you the mineral side. Fiano gives you the rich side. Albillo Mayor sits in the middle, round and fresh, for the bottle you open on a Tuesday. None of them asks you to pay for the most famous white grape on earth.
The short answer
- Godello (Spain): pear, quince, citrus and wet stone. The closest thing to white Burgundy that isn't.
- Fiano (Italy): pear, hazelnut and a saline, faintly smoky depth. The rich Chardonnay swap that gets better with a few years.
- Albillo Mayor (Spain): green apple, white peach and fennel. Round like Chardonnay, fresher than most of it.
Which Chardonnay do you actually drink?
Chardonnay is the most planted premium white on earth, which makes it a moving target. It can be lean and flinty, or rich and buttery, or anything between, and the same word on the label covers all of it. So "like Chardonnay" is really two requests. If you want structure, stone and a white that tastes serious, you want a mineral grape. If you want weight, nuttiness and something that fills the glass, you want a richer one. What both camps share is texture, and that's the part you can find elsewhere.
| Grape | Gives you | Style |
|---|---|---|
| Godello | Mineral structure | Unoaked, stony |
| Fiano | Richness | Nutty, weighty |
| Albillo Mayor | Roundness | Fresh, everyday |
Godello: the white-Burgundy one
Valdeorras, Galicia, Spain · medium body, high acid · go-DEH-yoh
Godello comes from Galicia in northwest Spain, and it's compared to white Burgundy so often that the nickname sticks. It's textural, mineral and structured, with green apple, pear and wet stone over a fuller body than you'd expect from a white this fresh. It's also the most ageworthy wine on this list.
Versus Chardonnay: this is your swap for serious, unoaked Chardonnay. Same texture, same sense that a white wine can hold your attention for a whole dinner, with more stone and less polish.
The catch: no butter and no vanilla. If the oak is the part of Chardonnay you love, Godello won't supply it.
Look for: a producer your shop stands behind, and ask them by name.
Fiano: the rich, ancient one
Campania, Italy · weighty, textural · fee-AH-no
One of southern Italy's oldest whites, Fiano is textural and weighty, with pear, hazelnut and a saline, faintly smoky depth. Unusually for a white, it gains complexity with a few years in bottle.
Versus Chardonnay: reach for it if you lean toward the nutty, honeyed, richer end of Chardonnay. It has the weight a rich Chardonnay has, and it brings its own nuttiness to the glass.
The catch: it's the wrong half for the lean, flinty drinker. If your Chardonnay is the steely kind, go to Godello instead.
Look for: a producer your shop stands behind, and ask them by name.
Albillo Mayor: the rounder one
Ribera del Duero, Spain · medium body, fresh · ahl-BEE-yoh mah-YOR
Albillo Mayor is the white grape hiding inside Ribera del Duero. It gives you fresh orchard fruit and citrus over a fuller, more textural body, with a fennel note and a bitter-almond edge at the finish.
Versus Chardonnay: your swap for the easygoing, rounder Chardonnay you pour without ceremony. It's rounder than a Sauvignon Blanc and fresher than most Chardonnay, which puts it right where an everyday white should sit.
The catch: almost nobody knows it exists, which is the charm and the problem. Expect to ask for it rather than find it on the shelf.
Look for: a producer your shop stands behind, and ask them by name.
Read the Albillo Mayor deep dive →
Where to buy
I haven't confirmed a specific bottle of any of these in stock online this month, so I'm not linking one. US availability is uneven, and Albillo Mayor is the one most likely to need a specialist shop or an order. Take the grape names to a shop you trust and let them tell you which producer they'd put their own name behind.
One thing I owe you plainly: I haven't tasted these three side by side yet. When I have, the bottles I'd buy go here, and this guide gets shorter.
One more for the mineral camp: Pošip, Croatia's serious white, often called its answer to white Burgundy. It's even harder to find than these three, so treat it as the bottle to grab when you see it.
New to the overlooked grapes? Join the Pack, one overlooked wine at a time. Or see the whole approach in Order This Instead.
Part of Lesser-Known Wines: 17 Obscure Grapes Worth Switching To, the full underdog-swap guide.
New to wine? Start here
Wine Match
Five guilty pleasures, yes or no. Ben finds the wine you’d actually like. You don’t need to know anything about wine. Ben certainly doesn’t.
Wine Underdogs is for readers of legal drinking age.
BenFive things. Yes or no. I'll do the rest.
Every wine fact here comes from the grape guides on Wine Underdogs. Ben has never opened a bottle, and neither does this game. For readers 21 and over.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best alternative to Chardonnay?
Godello is the closest match for lovers of serious, textural Chardonnay. It's compared to white Burgundy so often that the nickname stuck. Fiano suits those who like a richer, nuttier style that gains with a few years in bottle, and Albillo Mayor gives you Chardonnay's roundness with more freshness.
Is there an unoaked alternative to Chardonnay?
Yes. Godello and Albillo Mayor both give you Chardonnay's weight and texture without heavy oak, so you keep the body you like with more mineral freshness and no butter-and-vanilla overlay.
Are these cheaper than Chardonnay?
Usually. You aren't paying for the most famous white grape on earth, so serious bottles of Godello, Fiano and Albillo Mayor tend to over-deliver for the money against equivalent Chardonnay.
JOIN THE PACK
Whatever you drink now, there's an underdog you'd like more.
One overlooked wine at a time: what it tastes like, the famous one it can replace, and the catch. Free.